Morgan Silver Dollar (1878–1921)
1878–1921
The Morgan silver dollar is the most widely collected classic series in American numismatics, the study and collecting of coins. It takes its name from George T. Morgan, the British die-sinker, an engraver who cuts the steel dies that stamp a coin's design, whom the Philadelphia Mint hired in 1876. The coin was struck from 1878 to 1904, and then once more for a single year in 1921. Pick one up and you feel the heft right away. Each coin is 38.1 mm across and weighs 26.73 grams (412.5 grains). It is 90 percent silver and 10 percent copper, which works out to 0.7734 troy ounce of pure silver in every piece. The obverse, the front or 'heads' side, shows Liberty in profile. Morgan modeled her on Anna Willess Williams, a Philadelphia schoolteacher. She wears a Phrygian cap, the soft peaked cap that has long stood for freedom, with a ribbon reading LIBERTY and a crown of wheat and cotton. The reverse, the back or 'tails' side, shows an eagle with its wings outstretched, holding arrows and an olive branch. Five mints struck the coin, and each left a small letter called a mintmark to show where a coin was made. Philadelphia used no mintmark. The others were Carson City (CC), San Francisco (S), New Orleans (O), and, in 1921 only, Denver (D). You will find the mintmark on the reverse, beneath the bow of the wreath and between the D and O of DOLLAR. The coin was authorized by the Bland–Allison Act of 1878 and later fed by silver bought under the Sherman Silver Purchase Act. Over its run the series grew into a whole world for collectors. It includes the 1878 tail-feather varieties, in which the number of feathers in the eagle's tail changed partway through the first year. It includes Philadelphia Proofs for every year through 1904, Proofs being coins struck with extra care from polished dies for collectors. There are a handful of Branch Mint Proofs, the 1921 Chapman Proofs and Zerbe Special Strikes, and thousands of VAM die varieties, small differences between individual dies catalogued under a system we describe below. The keys of the series, the dates hardest to find and the ones that complete a collection, are the 1889-CC, the 1893-S and the Proof-only 1895.
- Total items
- 109
- Key / semi-key
- 13
- Composition
- 90% silver, 10% copper
- Weight
- 26.73 g
- Diameter
- 38.1 mm
- Pure silver
- 24.055 g · 0.7734 ozt
The Morgan dollar was born out of the silver politics of the 1870s, and its story makes more sense once you know a little of that quarrel. In 1873 Congress passed the Fourth Coinage Act. That law ended the free coining of silver, the old right to bring silver to the Mint and have it struck into legal-tender dollars for a small fee. It also dropped the Seated Liberty standard dollar in favor of a Trade dollar meant for commerce in Asia. At first there was little protest. That changed when silver prices fell, as Western mines poured out metal and the Panic of 1873 bit. Mining interests, farmers and manufacturers who wanted a bigger money supply came together in what was called the 'free silver' movement. In 1876 Representative Richard P. Bland of Missouri pushed a free-coinage bill through the House. In the Senate, William B. Allison of Iowa struck the free-coinage clause and put a different rule in its place: the Treasury would have to buy between two and four million dollars' worth of silver every month and coin it into dollars. The bill also authorized silver certificates for the first time. These were paper notes that could be exchanged for silver. President Rutherford B. Hayes vetoed the bill, and Congress overrode him on February 28, 1878. That law is the Bland–Allison Act you will see named on these pages. Mint Director Henry Linderman had already prepared for it. In 1876 he asked the Royal Mint in London to find him 'a first-class die-sinker', and Deputy Master C. W. Fremantle recommended George Morgan, who was then 30. Morgan arrived in Philadelphia on October 9, 1876, as an assistant engraver under Chief Engraver William Barber. What he did next tells you a good deal about the care that went into this coin. He enrolled at the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts and studied the bald eagle from nature. For Liberty he wanted an American woman rather than a Greek figure. His friend the painter Thomas Eakins suggested Anna Willess Williams of Philadelphia, and she sat for him five times. Morgan declared her profile the most perfect he had seen. On the coin, Liberty wears a Phrygian cap with a LIBERTY ribbon and a crown of wheat and cotton, two of the nation's leading crops. Morgan's design was first struck in 1877 as a pattern half dollar. A pattern is a trial piece made to test a design, not a coin made for spending. In October 1877 Linderman ordered dollar dies from the design. In February 1878 he told the Philadelphia superintendent that if the silver bill passed, he meant to adopt Morgan's dies rather than Barber's. Production began on March 11, 1878, more than a week after the act passed. The first acceptable coin came off the press at 3:17 p.m. and went to President Hayes. The next two went to Treasury Secretary John Sherman and to Linderman. Philadelphia stopped all other coinage and worked overtime to meet the monthly quota. In the second week Linderman pointed out what he called a 'slight imperfection', and two changes followed. The relief, meaning how high the design stands up from the flat surface of the coin, was lowered so that the dies would last longer. The eagle's tail feathers were also cut from eight to seven, because earlier U.S. coinage had always shown an odd number. The historian Q. David Bowers notes that Morgan's 1877 pattern halves and his early 1878 pattern dollars all had seven feathers, so in his view the eight-feather coin was the odd one out. That change in the middle of production created the 1878 Philadelphia progression collectors look for today. A word of explanation helps here. The design is pressed into each working die from a master tool called a hub. When the hub changed, some dies already made were pressed again with the new one. That gives us four types. First is the 8 Tail Feathers, with 749,500 struck. Next is the 7/8 Tail Feathers, made from dies re-impressed with the new hub. Then come two 7 Tail Feathers types: one with the flat-breast, parallel-arrow-feather Reverse of 1878, and one with the round-breast, slanted-arrow-feather Reverse of 1879, which became the standard design. Dies reached San Francisco and Carson City on April 16, 1878. New Orleans joined in 1879. Denver struck the coin only in 1921. Everyday commerce had limited appetite for such heavy coins. Vast numbers went straight from the presses into canvas bags in Treasury vaults, while silver certificates circulated in their place. Keep that picture of sealed bags in mind, because it shapes nearly everything about which coins survive today. On July 14, 1890, the Sherman Silver Purchase Act replaced Bland–Allison. It forced the Treasury to buy 4.5 million troy ounces of silver a month, but it required dollar coinage only into 1891. Mintages, the number of coins struck, fell sharply in 1892. When the Panic of 1893 brought bank runs and failures, President Grover Cleveland called a special session of Congress, and the purchase clause was repealed on November 1, 1893. The slowdown produced the rarities of 1893 to 1895: the 1893-S (100,000 struck), the 1893-O (300,000, the lowest New Orleans figure), the 1894 (110,000) and the Proof-only 1895. Carson City had been closed from 1885 until October 1889. It struck its last coins in the spring of 1893 and never coined again, and its mint status was withdrawn in 1899. On June 13, 1898, Congress ordered the rest of the Sherman Act silver coined into dollars. That drove mintages up again until the silver ran out in 1904 and production stopped. The First World War brought the coin back. German propaganda in India sparked a run on Britain's silver-backed notes. In response, Senator Key Pittman of Nevada sponsored the Pittman Act of April 22, 1918, which authorized the melting of up to 350 million silver dollars. In all, 270,232,722 were melted, and 259,121,554 of them were sold to the United Kingdom at one dollar per troy ounce. No record was kept of which dates went into the furnaces. That last point matters a great deal to collectors. It is why the mintage figure for a Morgan dollar is such a poor guide to how many survive. A date with a large mintage may have been melted almost entirely, while a small one may have been spared. The act also required that every melted dollar be replaced with a new one. When recoinage began in 1921, the new Peace dollar design was not ready. The Treasury had destroyed the obsolete Morgan dies in 1910, so Morgan, who had been Chief Engraver since Charles Barber's death in February 1917, had to cut an entirely new master die. Philadelphia, Denver and San Francisco struck more than 86 million 1921 Morgans before the Peace dollar replaced the design late that year. Two great releases later reshaped the collecting world. The first came from the Treasury itself. Until 1964 anyone could redeem a silver certificate for a silver dollar. In 1962 a rare coin turned up in a Philadelphia Mint bag, and lines formed at the Treasury Building in Washington, some people bringing wheelbarrows. Millions of dollars were paid out between November 1962 and March 1964. In the vaults, the Treasury found slightly more than 2.8 million Carson City dollars and held them back. A Joint Commission on Coinage met in May 1969, and legislation followed on December 31, 1970. The General Services Administration, or GSA, then sold the coins in seven mail-bid sales between 1972 and 1980, mounted in plastic holders, raising about $107 million. The GSA counts explain some of the odd survival patterns among the Carson City dates. The hoard held 962,638 of the 1,136,000 1884-CC dollars, 148,285 of the 228,000 1885-CC and 147,485 of the 296,000 1881-CC. The 1889-CC, 1892-CC and 1893-CC, by contrast, were each represented by a single coin. Private hoards mattered too. LaVere Redfield, a recluse in Reno, left about 400 bags at his death in 1976, roughly 400,000 coins, most of them from the San Francisco Mint and most of them Uncirculated. The even larger Continental-Illinois Bank hoard appeared in the 1980s. There is no single right way to collect Morgan dollars, and collectors have found many paths through the series. Some build a date-and-mintmark set, one coin for each year and mint, anchored by the Big Three: the 1889-CC, the 1893-S and the Proof 1895. Others build the thirteen-coin Carson City set. Some follow the Proofs from 1878 to 1904 and add the 1921 Chapman and Zerbe pieces. Others hunt condition rarities, dates that are easy to find worn but very hard to find in top condition. The 1884-S, 1892-S and 1895-O are examples: common worn, but almost unobtainable in Gem, the term for a coin in exceptional condition. Still others collect by die variety under the VAM system, named for Leroy Van Allen and A. George Mallis, who catalogued the tiny differences between individual dies. Their Top 100 and Hit List 40 are catalogued by PCGS, the Professional Coin Grading Service. The last specialty is the prooflike coin. Prooflike (PL) and Deep Mirror Prooflike (DMPL) coins are ordinary business strikes, coins made for circulation, whose fields shine like mirrors because they were struck from fresh dies. The fields are the flat background areas around the design.
Key & Semi-Key Dates
Choose a finish
This series was struck in 3 finishes. Choose one to see its coins.
Values are informational estimates, not appraisals or financial advice. The Grateful Estimate is an estimated true value worked down from current Buy It Now asking prices on eBay for the service and grade shown. N/A means no current listing matches. How it's made.


